Denial reason · Coverage
Cosmetic
Do this first
Both are free and run in your browser.
Your plan says the surgery or treatment is meant to change how you look, not to treat a medical problem. The fight is usually over whether it treats a real medical or functional problem, and over the plan's own definition of cosmetic.
On this page 7
- Who has to act first
- You and your provider together. You file the appeal. Your surgeon or doctor has to document the medical problem in the records and in a letter, because that is the evidence the plan looks for.
- Can it go to external review?
- Sometimes. It depends on what the decision turns on. A plain plan exclusion is not a medical-judgment denial. But whether your condition is a medical problem that needs the treatment is a medical question, and the independent reviewer decides whether medical judgment is involved.
Wording you may see on your letter
- Cosmetic procedures are excluded from coverage
- This service is performed to improve appearance and is not medically necessary
- Cosmetic in nature; no functional impairment documented
- Services to reshape normal structures of the body are not covered
What it means
“Cosmetic” is a label. Your plan is saying the service is meant to change your appearance and falls under an exclusion in the plan document. But some surgery that looks cosmetic treats a medical or functional problem, and the plan has to apply its own words to your situation. Your first job is to find out what the plan means by “cosmetic” and what it decided about your condition.
The notice must say which plan provision it relied on. If the denial rests on medical judgment, it must either explain the clinical reasoning as it applies to your circumstances or say that the explanation is free on request. Ask for both.
Who has to act first
You file the appeal, but your doctor’s records carry it. Ask your surgeon or doctor to document the medical problem, not only the result you want.
For a job-based plan or a non-grandfathered individual plan, you have at least 180 days after you receive the denial notice to file the first appeal; your plan may allow more. Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, Veterans Affairs and federal employee plans have different, often shorter, deadlines. Check the date on your notice, which controls.
Arguments that work
- Use the plan’s own definition. Get the exclusion text from the plan document. Quote it, and show where your situation falls outside it.
- Show a medical or functional problem. Pain, trouble breathing, infection, difficulty eating or moving, skin breakdown, or other effects documented in your records support a medical-necessity case. Treatments you already tried that failed help too.
- Ask for the clinical explanation. A one-line label does not apply the plan’s terms to your medical circumstances.
- Qualified reviewers. The appeal must be decided by someone other than the first decision-maker, with a health professional of appropriate training consulted who was not consulted the first time.
- Breast reconstruction after a mastectomy is not optional coverage. A plan that covers mastectomy must cover all stages of reconstruction of the affected breast, surgery on the other breast for symmetry, prostheses, and treatment of complications including lymphedema. A self-funded government plan that has formally opted out of this requirement is the exception, so check.
Evidence to gather
- The exclusion text and the plan’s definitions (the plan; ask in writing).
- Clinical notes, measurements and photographs that show the problem (your doctor).
- A letter from the surgeon on the medical problem, what was tried, and why this treatment (your surgeon).
- Records of treatments you tried first (your doctor or pharmacy).
- The plan’s claim file, including its clinical criteria (the plan, free on request).
What to send
Send a written appeal quoting the plan’s definition, with the surgeon’s letter and your records. Use the not-a-covered-benefit appeal letter or the medical necessity letter, depending on whether the plan relied on the exclusion or on medical necessity. If the plan upholds the denial and your plan is not grandfathered, you have at least four months after that final denial to request external review.
When this is not worth an appeal
If the procedure is purely for appearance, the plan document clearly excludes it, and your records show no functional or medical problem, an appeal has little to stand on. Ask the provider for the cash price and a payment plan, and ask whether it offers financial assistance.